Spring 2019
Photo by
Cappy Johnston
Inside:
“Celebrating Shaw’s 150th”
“Little Orchard” 1897
1917 image of Shaw’s Market Square, shortly after completion.
Howard Van Doren Shaw at 150:
Photo Copyright 1917
E.L. Fowler
Assessing the Architect
on this Significant Anniversary of His Birth in Chicago
Howard Van Doren Shaw, an architect of major significance to Lake Forest, was born on May 7, 1869, 150 years ago. One day short of age 57, May 6, 1926, as he lay dying in Baltimore, he learned that he was selected to be awarded the 9th American Institute of Architects Gold Medal, for presentation at the 1927 AIA Annual meeting. Shaw slipped away just as he received word of the award being approved, almost his last thought his pleasure at this recognition. Perhaps he also grasped the significance of the award going to an American architect whose practice was located in Chicago, west of the East Coast’s centers of architectural power and authority.
Shaw’s American Institute of Architects Gold Medal is often cited, but rarely discussed. Shaw was the ninth recipient of this recognition begun in 1907, and the fourth American so honored, with four of the other nine being English and French architects. The well-known architectural historian Richard Guy Wilson, in his 1984 book, The AIA Gold Medal, divided the Gold Medalists into cohorts or generations, with Shaw being in the second group of Americans. In this group, he followed Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue (1925), the architect of Rockefeller Chapel at the University of Chicago, completed in 1930. The earlier group of Americans had studied abroad and their work reflected French classicism. According to Wilson, the second cohort including Shaw was made up of a new generation of U.S.-trained architects, such as Shaw, who studied at MIT’s architecture school in 1891, the year after he graduated from Yale. The awardees in this cohort, by Wilson’s analysis, strove for more picturesque and emotional effects even while relying on classic planning and guidance. Henry Bacon (1923), from the first group of honorees, had begun his education at the German-inspired architecture program at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, prior to extensive travel in Europe.
Portrait of Howard Van Doren Shaw
Bacon, though, practiced on the East Coast, creating the structure for the 1923 Lincoln Memorial, Washington, DC. Shaw, with his office in Chicago, was the first of the Americans honored with the Gold Medal to practice in the Midwest. It was a couple of decades later that the AIA honored with Gold Medals Chicagoans Louis Sullivan (1944, posthumously) and Frank Lloyd Wright (1949). By 1957 the AIA began to honor a new generation of Chicago modernists, with Louis Skidmore. But Howard Shaw was the first Midwestern practicing Gold Medalist.
Shaw’s practice was among the most varied by type of project among his AIA U.S. Gold Medalist peers: residential design for a variety of settings, including city, town, and suburban/country place, subdivision, campus, and industrial-town; commercial, including
automobile show rooms and shops; public auditoriums; clubs; churches; warehouses; industrial; high-rises; a planned company town; and mixed-use—as at Lake Forest’s Market Square. Shaw’s body of work also varied geographically, mostly around the Midwest (Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, and Wisconsin, plus a commercial building in New York City and a cottage for his father-in-law, Connecticut). He was, as well, a partner in real estate development in Lake Forest: his 1897 North Green Bay Road three-estate development on a Swanton farm, his 1906 Atteridge farm mixed middle-class residential and recreational plan, and his Lake Forest estate houses. Real estate development also included in Chicago his 1910 and 1920s lakefront apartment buildings, again, in Lake Forest, with his 1912-17 Market Square, and in Indiana with his only partially-realized 1918 Marktown model factory village, East Chicago. Virginia A. Greene’s 1998 book on Shaw and his work documents this range of commissions.
Shaw practiced under his own name without a full partner. He did, however, employ capable trained draftsmen, beginning with Armour Institute-trained architect Robert Work in 1897, and others such as engineer George Eich, David Adler, Stanley Anderson. There also were Ralph Milman, who continued to practice in Lake Forest, Bertrand Weber who built homes in Lake Forest and Highland Park, and other engineers, likely beginning in a major way with the first 1898-1902 Donnelley Lakeside Press plant, Chicago’s Printers’ Row.
Perhaps Shaw’s most galvanizing work among his architect peers was Market Square, 1916. This was a significant coup of trans-Atlantic British modern town and U.S. City Beautiful planning. It was envisioned, planned, strikingly designed, and built under his exacting
2
supervision, supervision revealed in the original plans discovered in 1999 in the John Griffith office archive. As revealed in those plans, Market Square has come to be recognized as a majorstepincreatinganewtypeofbuiltprojectin the 20th century, the town center planned around convenient motor vehicle access, later identified as the “shopping center.” This catapulted the Lake Forest version of this new type into Hegeman’s book on trans-Atlantic, but mostly European, civic art in 1922, as noted in Stuart Cohen’s 2015 book on Shaw’s residential design.
The tremendous success of Shaw’s suburban and country houses between the Alleghenies and the Rockies was a major achievement. His work tied together threads of classic planning and, sometimes, design with English Arts & Crafts ideals, integrating gardens into house designs, while also using subtilty, materials, and construction methods reflecting modern design trends. Shaw often anchored his planned and developed residential projects with places for him and his family: Ragdale, one of the three estates on the Swanton farm, 1897; his Lake Shore Drive co-op with his town residence on the top floor, 1910; and his early 1920’s larger apartment house near Fullerton, Chicago, again with his own apartment.
Overcome in mid-life by chronic illness, at age fifty-six in 1926, he cut back and then died as the boom of the 1920’s was just beginning. His peer, Lake Forest resident Alfred H. Granger, born in 1867, lived on and practiced in Chicago for another decade and a half of influence. Shaw’s talent did not survive to influence the further refinement of the Market Square type of development elsewhere in that decade, which would have been a logical follow-up. Instead, other architects took the next steps, such as Edwin Hill Clark at Plaza del Lago, Wilmette, 1925. Even so, Shaw’s genius in residential design, detailed in Stuart Cohen’s 2015 study, was passed on to his associate and mentee, David Adler. Richard Guy Wilson, writing in the Art Institute’s 2002 book on Adler, found Adler to be the leading traditional architect of his period—the first third of the 20th century. Shaw’s later associate, Stanley D. Anderson, worked on a variety of buildings that continued the Gold Medalist’s English Arts & Crafts and classic templates intensively in Lake Forest and also beyond–across the North Shore and following his clients to resorts from the seashore to the Rockies.
*The discussions of (1) Shaw’s AIA Gold Medal with his being the first Midwestern-practicing awardee and of (2) the significance of Market Square draw on a draft by Arthur H. Miller for a book on Shaw’s Market Square, the draft currently out for review at a university press.
supervision, supervision revealed in the original plans discovered in 1999 in the John Griffith office archive. As revealed in those plans, Market Square has come to be recognized as a majorstepincreatinganewtypeofbuiltprojectin the 20th century, the town center planned around convenient motor vehicle access, later identified as the “shopping center.” This catapulted the Lake Forest version of this new type into Hegeman’s book on trans-Atlantic, but mostly European, civic art in 1922, as noted in Stuart Cohen’s 2015 book on Shaw’s residential design.
The tremendous success of Shaw’s suburban and country houses between the Alleghenies and the Rockies was a major achievement. His work tied together threads of classic planning and, sometimes, design with English Arts & Crafts ideals, integrating gardens into house designs, while also using subtilty, materials, and construction methods reflecting modern design trends. Shaw often anchored his planned and developed residential projects with places for him and his family: Ragdale, one of the three estates on the Swanton farm, 1897; his Lake Shore Drive co-op with his town residence on the top floor, 1910; and his early 1920’s larger apartment house near Fullerton, Chicago, again with his own apartment.
Overcome in mid-life by chronic illness, at age fifty-six in 1926, he cut back and then died as the boom of the 1920’s was just beginning. His peer, Lake Forest resident Alfred H. Granger, born in 1867, lived on and practiced in Chicago for another decade and a half of influence. Shaw’s talent did not survive to influence the further refinement of the Market Square type of development elsewhere in that decade, which would have been a logical follow-up. Instead, other architects took the next steps, such as Edwin Hill Clark at Plaza del Lago, Wilmette, 1925. Even so, Shaw’s genius in residential design, detailed in Stuart Cohen’s 2015 study, was passed on to his associate and mentee, David Adler. Richard Guy Wilson, writing in the Art Institute’s 2002 book on Adler, found Adler to be the leading traditional architect of his period—the first third of the 20th century. Shaw’s later associate, Stanley D. Anderson, worked on a variety of buildings that continued the Gold Medalist’s English Arts & Crafts and classic templates intensively in Lake Forest and also beyond–across the North Shore and following his clients to resorts from the seashore to the Rockies.
*The discussions of (1) Shaw’s AIA Gold Medal with his being the first Midwestern-practicing awardee and of (2) the significance of Market Square draw on a draft by Arthur H. Miller for a book on Shaw’s Market Square, the draft currently out for review at a university press.
Historic Second Presbyterian Church:
Restoring Chicago’s Arts & Crafts Jewel
Sunday, March 17, 3:00 PM • Gorton Community Center
Historic Second Presbyterian Church in Chicago’s South Loop played an important role in Lake Forest’s early development and ever since has shared strong connections to the city’s institutions and residents, including
the First Presbyterian Church of Lake Forest, Lake Forest College, and Lake Forest architect Howard Van Doren Shaw, himself, who designed Second Presbyterian’s landmarked 1901 Arts & Crafts interior.
Glessner House Executive Director and Curator Bill Tyre and architect Nate Lielasus will discuss the history of Chicago’s Second Presbyterian Church, its ties to Lake Forest, and recent efforts to restore this National Historic Landmark.
Program free of charge, reservation requested – LFPF.org
Next Event
Historic Second Presbyterian Church:
Restoring Chicago’s Arts & Crafts Jewel
Sunday, March 17, 3:00 PM • Gorton Community Center
Historic Second Presbyterian Church in Chicago’s South Loop played an important role in Lake Forest’s early development and ever since has shared strong connections to the city’s institutions and residents, including
the First Presbyterian Church of Lake Forest, Lake Forest College, and Lake Forest architect Howard Van Doren Shaw, himself, who designed Second Presbyterian’s landmarked 1901 Arts & Crafts interior.
Glessner House Executive Director and Curator Bill Tyre and architect Nate Lielasus will discuss the history of Chicago’s Second Presbyterian Church, its ties to Lake Forest, and recent efforts to restore this National Historic Landmark.
Program free of charge, reservation requested – LFPF.org
Next Event
Plaque by Sylvia Shaw Judson of her father, copied by Paul Myers.
At Lake Forest College Library Special Collections.
Join the Celebration
150th Anniversary
of the Birth of
Howard Van Doren Shaw
Saturday, May 11, 2019 k 9:30 a.m.
Second Presbyterian Church
1936 South Michigan Avenue, Chicago
A Half-Day Symposium
Organized by Glessner House and Its Director, William Tyre
More about this Symposium, its speakers and topics, can be found at
https://www.glessnerhouse.org/programs/. The Symposium’s admission charge of
$25 offers a very full program with experts discussing Ragdale’s preservation, Shaw and the Arts & Crafts Movement in turn-of-the-20th-century Chicago,
and Market Square. Art Miller will present on Market Square. The event is partially
funded by the Donnelley Foundation and by the Lake Forest Preservation Foundation.
Shaw renovated the notable 1871 James Renwick-designed Second Presbyterian Church in 1899 after a fire. Glessner House, 1801 S. Prairie Avenue, leads studies on the history of the Prairie Avenue District, including the 1860’s house of Sarah Van Doren and
Theodore Shaw (demolished. 1937), where Shaw was born in 1869.
That was the year of the completion of the trans-continental railroad and
Annual Holiday Celebration
Thank you to Meredith Mitchell for closing our yearlong
celebration of the works of Stanley Anderson at her beautiful, iconic SDA home on December 2nd.
What a great year 2018 was; we have lots to be thankful for!
Annual Holiday Celebration
Thank you to Meredith Mitchell for closing our yearlong
celebration of the works of Stanley Anderson at her beautiful, iconic SDA home on December 2nd.
What a great year 2018 was; we have lots to be thankful for!
two years before the Chicago Fire.
two years before the Chicago Fire.3
Thank You To our 2018 MeMbers, Donors, VolunTeers anD sponsors
MeMbership
Mr. and Mrs. Anthony Abbattista * Ms. Nancy Akred
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Alfe Mr. and Mrs. James Allen * Mr. Stanley Anderson
Ms. Sara Anderson *
Mr. and Mrs. James Armstrong Mr. and Mrs. Bill Athenson Ms. Rachel Noel Avigad
and Mr. Paul Piotrowski * Ms. Brunhild Baass
Mr. Chris Bacon
Mr. and Mrs. David Baier Mr. Dan Baigelman
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Banks Ms. Caryl Barclay
Mr. and Mrs. Steven Barnhart Mr. and Mrs. Patrick Barry Mr. and Mrs. Howard Bass Mr. and Mrs. Ralph Behrens
Mr. and Mrs. Francis Beidler III Ms. Patti Belmonti
Mr. and Mrs. Wayne Benjamin * Mr. and Mrs. Bruce Bennett
Mr. and Mrs. Edward Bennett III * Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Bent *
Mrs. Joan Bent *
Mr. Craig Bergmann and Mr. Paul Klug Mr. Paul Bergmann *
Mr. and Mrs. Doug Cassidy Mr. Bill Castle
Mr. and Mrs. Nicholas Chabraja Ms. Catherine Champ
Ms. Annette Champion Mrs. Clarissa Chandler Mr. and Mrs. Ed Chandler Mr. and Mrs. Luke Chang Mr. Richard Chapman
Mr. and Mrs. Tom Cirrincione Mr. Jerome Claeys
Ms. Debbie Clark Mr. Stuart Cohen
and Ms. Julie Hacker Mr. and Mrs. Steve Cole
Mr. and Mrs. Liam Connell Mr. and Mrs. Vince Conroy Mr. and Mrs. Ron Coolley Mrs. Katie Cordell
Mr. and Mrs. Peter Coutant * Mr. George Covington
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Crawford * Mr. and Mrs. Scott Cummings Mr. and Mrs. Michael Cummins Mr. and Mrs. Todd Curry
Mr. Richard Cutler
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Daly
Mr. and Mrs Neal Dann-Fenwick Mr. James DeActis
and Ms. Anne Morgan *
Dr. Alexia Gordon
Mr. and Mrs. Theodore Grabbe Mrs. Leslie Graham
Mr. and Mrs. Tom Grant Mr. Edward Gray
Mr. and Mrs. Will Gregg
Mr. and Mrs. David Grinnell * Mrs. Katharina Grossi
Mr. and Mrs. Ernst Haberli Ms. Blanche Hall
Dr. and Mrs. James Hall Mr. and Mrs. Ed Halle Mrs. Elizabeth Hamilton Mr. Philippe Hans
Mr. Gunny Harboe Mr. Phil Hartung
Ms. Sharon A. Harvey
Mr. and Mrs. Michael Havey * Mr. and Mrs. Ed Hayman
Mr. Douglas Hayward Mrs. Molly Heizer Mr. Kip Helverson
and Mr. Trey Gonzales * Mr. and Mrs. David Henkel
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel J. Henry * Mrs. Carrol Herber *
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Hermes Ms. Susan Hetzel
Ms. Lucia Heyworth Ms. Mary Lynne Hickey
Mr. and Mrs. John Kozak Mr. and Mrs. Paul Krauss * Mrs. Posy Krehbiel
Mr. and Mrs. Alvin Kruse Mr. Desmond La Place * Lake Forest Garden Club * Lake Forest Open Lands
Mr. and Mrs. Charles Lamphere Mr. and Mrs. Michael Lane
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Lanigan Mr. and Mrs. James Leahy Mr. and Mrs. Sean Leahy
Mr. Michael Lewandowski Ms. Linda Liang *
Mr. and Mrs. Andrew Lind Mr. Mark Linenberg *
Mr. and Mrs. David Linville Mr. and Mrs. William Lloyd Mrs. Susan Lovell
Mr. and Mrs. Geoffrey Luce * Mr. Don Lynch
and Ms. Lori Lennon
Mr. and Mrs. William Madden Ms. Mary Anna Malich
Mr. and Ms. Jeff Mandel
Mr. and Mrs. Reese Marcusson * Mrs. Miles Marsh
Mrs. Carol Marwede
Mr. and Mrs. David Mathis * Mr. David Mattoon *
Ms. Andra O’Neill Mr. C. J. Oates
and Dr. Heather Heiberger Mr. Larry Obermeyer
and Ms. Anne O’Connell Mr. and Mrs. James Opsitnik * Mrs. Shirley Paddock
Mr. and Mrs. Kurt Pairitz
Mr. and Mrs. George Pandaleon Mrs. Ellen Peter
Ms. Evelyn Phelps Mrs. Judy Polk
Mr. and Mrs. Alex Pollock Mr. Christopher Pommer and Mrs. Lisa Pommer Ms. Carol Post
Mr. Byron Prais
Mr. and Mrs. Rick Preiss
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Price * Mrs. Juliet Priebe
Mr. James Proesel
Mr. Todd Protzman-Davis Ms. Kathleen Pyle
Mrs. Diane Quinn
Mr. and Mrs. David Radcliffe Ms. Kathy Rafferty *
Mr. and Mrs. Tom Rajkovich Dr. and Mrs. Nabih Ramadan * Mr. William Redfield *
Mr. and Mrs. Jack Reilly
Mr. and Mrs. Christopher Bernish
Mr. and Mrs. Phillip Deemer *
Mr. Steve Hill and Ms. Eva Heilman Mr. and Mrs. Brian Maxwell
Mr. and Mrs. Patrick Reinkemeyer
Mr. and Mrs. Harold Bernthal Mr. and Mrs. James Bertram Mr. and Mrs. Robert Binkley Mr. and Mrs. Mark Bischoff Mr. and Mrs. William Block Mrs. William Boggess
Mrs. Nancy Bolton Ms. Suzanne Boren * Mr. and Mrs. Jim Borg Messrs. Richard Bories and James Shearron
Mr. and Mrs. Charles Bowen * Ms. Ann Bowen
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Brandel Ms. Nancy Brankis *
Mr. and Mrs. Leland Brewester Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Brewster * Mr. and Mrs. Don Brown
Mr. and Mrs. Cameron Brown Mrs. Jean Brown
Mr. Robert Brown Mr. Jackson Brown *
Ms. Anna Marie Brucker Mr. and Mrs. David Bruskin Mrs. John Bryan *
Mr. and Mrs. James Bryant Dr. and Mrs. Brian Bryzinski * Dr. Barbara Buchbinder
Mrs. Mignon Buehler
Mr. and Mrs. David Burgess Mr. Raymond Buschmann * Mrs. Rhett Butler *
Mr. John Capstick Mrs. Betty Carbol
Mr. and Mrs. George Cardenas Mr. and Mrs. Norman Carlson Mrs. Peter Carney
Mrs. Barry Carroll Ms. Julie Carter Ms. Patricia Carter Ms. Mollie Casey
4
Mr. and Mrs. Michael Deering Mr. and Mrs. Roger Deromedi * Mr. and Mrs. Tim Derr
Mr. and Mrs. David Dezelan Mr. and Mrs. Lowell Dixon * Mr. and Mrs. John Doheny Mrs. Barbara Donnelley
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Douglas Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Douglass Mr. John Drummond
and Ms. Rommy Lopat
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Dunbeck Mrs. Thomas E. Eckland
Ms. Adrienne Eckerling Mrs. Leeni Ellis
Ms. Laurel Kay Ellwein Mr. and Mrs. Bill Emerson
Mr. and Mrs. James Engelland Mr. and Mrs. Morton Engle Mr. and Mrs. James Estes
Mr. and Mrs. Les Finkel Mrs. Patricia Finn
Mr. Brian Floriani
Mr and Mrs. Anthony Fontana Mr. and Mrs. John Foran
Mr. James Fouts Ms. Maria Gabaldo
Mr. and Mrs. Ron Garriques Ms. Janet Gates
Ms. Susan Gaud Ms. Carol Gayle *
Mr. Perry Georgopoulos
Mr. and Mrs. Dan Gescheidle Mrs. R. Thomas Gibson
Ms. Jan Gibson Mr. Sean Gilmore Mr. Tom Gleason *
Mr. and Mrs. Ambrose Glombowski Mr. Jack Goggin
Dr. Hugh Gogins
Mr. and Mrs. Michael Goldstein
Mr. and Mrs. James Hodges * Mrs. Joyce Holson
Ms. Sharon Hoover
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Huber Ms. Sarah Hughes *
Mrs. William Hughes * Mr. and Mrs. Roger Hull Ms. Judith Inglese
Ms. Susan Ipsen *
Mr. and Mrs. James Isenberg Mr. and Mrs. Spencer Isola Mr. and Mrs. Fred Jackson * Dr. and Mrs. Bill Janes *
Mr. and Mrs. Allan Janis * Mr. and Mrs. Chris Jensen Mrs. Sarah Jimenez *
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Johnsen Mr. and Mrs. John Johnson Mr. and Mrs. Dennis Johnston Mrs. Rosemary Kehr
Mr. and Mrs. James Kenney Mr. and Mrs. Stewart Kerr * Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Kim Mr. and Mrs. Doug Kinney Mr. and Mrs. William Kirk Ms. Sally Kirkpatrick
Mrs. Donna Kissel Mr. Henry Kleeman
and Ms. Joan Boughton * Mr. Fred Klein
and Ms. Frieda Jacobs * Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Klein Mr. Carl Klein
Mrs. Robert Kleinert
Mr. and Mrs. Frank Klepitsch Ms. Betty Klingenberg
Mr. and Mrs. Bill Knauz Mr.and Mrs. Tim Knight Ms. Pamela Knowles
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Kolar Mr. and Mrs. Michael Koob
Mr. and Mrs. John McDonough Mr. and Mrs. William McFadden Ms. Mary Ellen McGoey
Mr. and Mrs. Tom McIntosh Ms. Kelly McKee
Ms. Mary McMahon Ms. Lisa McWeeny Ms. Mary McWilliams Ms. Diana Melichar
Mr. Richard Mentzinger * Mr. Terry Mieling
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Milani * Mrs. Pamela Miles
Mr. and Mrs. Arthur H. Miller * Ms. Meredith Mitchell
Mr. and Mrs. Roger Mohr * Mr. Steven Monz *
Mr. and Mrs. Scott Moore Mr. and Mrs. Chris Moore *
Mr. and Mrs. German Moreno Ms. Wendy Moreno
Mr. and Mrs. David Morgans Mr. and Mrs. Larry Mosner
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Moulton-Ely Mr. and Mrs. Fred Moyer *
Mr. and Mrs. John Mueller Mrs. Catherine Murphy Mr. and Mrs. Karl Nagel
Mr. and Mrs. Mark Neaman Dr. and Mrs. Mark Neerhof * Ms. Leslie Newman
Mr. and Mrs. Neil Nicastro Ms. Lois Nicol
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Norton Mr. Brian Norton
and Ms. Kathryn Grace Mr. and Mrs. John Notz * NSDAR *
Mr. Michael O’Connell
Mr. and Mrs. Jim O’Connor Mr. and Mrs. Peter O’Malley *
Mr. Lawrence
and Dr. Linda Remensnyder * Ms. Martha ReQua
Mr. Timm Reynolds Ms. Betty Rich
Mrs. Patricia Riess * Ms. Sandra Riggs *
Mr. Theodore Roberts * Ms. Sylvia Robinson Mr. Bill Robinson
and Ms. Nancy Green
Dr. and Mrs. Lawrence Roebel Mr. and Mrs. Frank. Rogalski Mr. Ted Rojahn
Mrs. James Roselle
Dr. Carlos and Dr. Carlotta Rotman
Ms. Monica Artmann Ruggles Mr. and Mrs. Edmond Russ Mr. and Mrs. William Russell Dr. Stephen Russo
and Dr. Anna Bendron Russo Mr. and Mrs. Bob Salzwedel Mr. and Mrs. Mark Saran
Ms. Katherine Saville Mr. Franz Schulze
Mr. and Mrs. Bill Schumann Mrs. William Searle *
Ms. Mary Seyfarth Mrs. Julia Shackleford Mrs. Hollis Shank
Mr. and Mrs. Kevin Shannahan Mr. and Mrs. Robert Shaw * Ms. Christine Shaw
Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Sheffield Mrs. Linda Shields *
Ms. Patricia Shuma and Mr. Craig Fox * Ms. Dianne Siekmann
Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Slavin Mr. and Mrs. Adrian Smith *
Preservation publication is provided three times a year to the entire community of Lake Forest free of charge through our generous members listed.
MeMbership, continued
Mr. Sidney T Smith
Mr. and Mrs. Carl Sommers Mrs. Mary Southworth
Ms. Linda Spanberger Ms. Elizabeth Sperry
Mr. and Mrs. Bill Sprague Ms. Dorr St. Clair
Col. and Mrs. Lawrence Stack * Dr. and Mrs. John Stamelos Mr. Charles Starcevich
Mr. and Mrs. Harrison Steans * Mr. and Mrs. James Stebbins * Ms. Kathleen Stevenson
Mr. and Mrs. James Stirling *
Mr. Jim Stokes Mrs. James Stokes Ms. Tina Strauss Mrs. Carole Stroh * Ms. Heather Strong
Mr. and Mrs. Walter Sunseri Mr. D. Jeffery Swinson
Mrs. Elizabeth Taylor Mrs. Beth Teich
Mr. and Mrs. Ken Temkin Ms. Marsha Temple
Mr. and Mrs. James TenBroek Ms. Anne Thomas
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Thomson *
Ms. Linda Tomchuck
Mr. and Mrs. John Travers * Mrs. Marilyn Turchi
Mrs. Robert Tweed Rev. Ronald Valentine
Mr. and Mrs. Jim Van Cleave Ms. Cathy Van Dorpe
Ms. Kathleen Van Ella
Ms. Betty Jean Van Gorkom Mr. Peter Van Nice
Mr. and Mrs. William Vance Ms. Cassandra Vermillion Dr. Alan and Mrs. Susan Stetson Vertrees
annual FunD
Mr. John Vratimos
Mr. and Mrs. Fred Wacker * Mr. Frank Waldeck *
Mr. and Mrs. Michael Walsh Mrs. Rheda Walton
Mr. and Mrs. Robert Washlow * Ms. Emily Watts
Mr. and Mrs. David Waud * Mr. and Mrs. Ron Waud Ms. Nicki Weeden *
Mrs. Louise Weithas
Mr. and Mrs. Peter West * Mr. and Mrs. Henry West
Mr. and Mrs. Tom Wettermann
Ms. Laura Whistler
Mr. and Mrs. Emmett White Mr. George White
Mrs. Donna Williams Ms. Louise Wilson
Mr. and Mrs. Paul Wisner Ms. Lisa Wolfe
and Mr. Mark Diganci * Dr. Susanne Woloson * Mr. and Mrs. Kirk Wolter
Mr. and Mrs. Arthur Wood Mrs. Anna Jean Woroch Ms. Gina Zisook
Mr. Lloyd Zuckerberg
- denotes Annual Fund donor also
Contibutions to the Annual Fund are dedicated to new local preservation efforts
Mr. and Mrs. Anthony Abbattista * Mr. and Mrs. James Allen *
Mr. James Anderson Ms. Sara Anderson * Ms. Rachel Noel Avigad
and Mr. Paul Piotrowski *
Mr. and Mrs. Wayne Benjamin * Mr. and Mrs. Edward Bennett III * Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Bent *
Mrs. Joan Bent *
Mr. Paul Bergmann * Ms. Suzanne Boren *
Mr. and Mrs. Charles Bowen * Ms. Nancy Brankis *
Mr. and Mrs. Chip Brennan
Mr. and Mrs. Stephen Brewster * Mr. Jackson Brown *
Mrs. John Bryan *
Dr. and Mrs. Brian Bryzinski * Mr. and Mrs. Googan Bunn Mr. Raymond Buschmann * Mrs. Rhett Butler *
Mr. and Mrs. David Cain Mr. and Mrs. Peter Cherry
Mr. and Mrs. Roger Christoph Mr. and Mrs. Peter Coutant * Mr. and Mrs. Robert Crawford * Mr. Richard Cutler
Mr. Mike Dau
Mr. and Mrs. John Davidson Mr. and Mrs. Toby Davis
Mr. James DeActis
and Ms. Anne Morgan *
Mr. and Mrs. Phillip Deemer * Mr. and Mrs. Roger Deromedi * Mr. and Mrs. Lowell Dixon * Mrs. Suzanne Dixon
Ms. Jennifer Donnelly
Ms. Charenton Zelov Drake Mrs. Maddie Dugan
Mr. and Mrs. Mathew Frekko Ms. Carol Gayle *
Mr. and Mrs. Otto Georgi Mr. and Mrs. Jim Glasser Mr. Tom Gleason *
Mr. John Glynn
Mr. and Mrs. Bruce Grieve Mr. D. Kendall Griffith
Mr. and Mrs. David Grinnell * Mr. and Mrs. Dennis Gross Mr. and Mrs. Michael Havey * Mr. Kip Helverson
and Mr. Trey Gonzales *
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel J. Henry * Mrs. Carrol Herber *
Mr. and Mrs. James Hodges * Dr. Eugene Hotchkiss
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Huber * Mrs. William Hughes *
Ms. Sarah Hughes *
Mr. and Mrs. Tom Hunter Ms. Susan Ipsen *
Mr. and Mrs. Fred Jackson * Dr. and Mrs. Bill Janes * Mr. and Mrs. Allan Janis * Mrs. Sarah Jimenez *
Mrs. Phyllis Johnson Mr. Thomas Keim
Mr. and Mrs. Jim Kellock Mr. and Mrs. Stewart Kerr * Mr. and Mrs. Bob Klaskin Mr. Henry Kleeman
and Ms. Joan Boughton * Mr. Fred Klein
and Ms. Frieda Jacobs * Mr. and Mrs. Paul Krauss * Lake Forest Garden Club * Mr. Desmond La Place * Ms. Linda Liang *
Mr. Mark Linenberg *
Mr. and Mrs. Geoffrey Luce * Mr. and Mrs. Reese Marcusson * Mr. and Mrs. Miles Marsh *
Mr. and Mrs. David Mathis * Mr. David Mattoon *
Mr. and Mrs. Keith McClintock Ms. Mary McWilliams
Mr. Richard Mentzinger * Mr. and Mrs. Robert Milani *
Mr. and Mrs. Arthur H. Miller * Mr. and Mrs. Roger Mohr *
Mr. Steven Monz *
Mr. and Mrs. Chris Moore *
Mr. and Mrs. David Moore Mr. and Mrs. James Morris Mr. and Mrs. Fred Moyer * Dr. and Mrs. Mark Neerhof * Mr. and Mrs. John Notz * NSDAR *
Mr. and Mrs. Peter O’Malley * Mr. and Mrs. Raymond Oddi Mr. and Mrs. James Opsitnik * Mrs. Shirley Paddock
Mr. and Mrs. Edward Pasquesi Mr. and Mrs. L. Robert Pasquesi Ms. Cheryl Pettit
Ms. Paula Polito
Mr. and Mrs. John Poth
Mr. and Mrs. John Preschlack Mr. and Mrs. Richard Price * Ms. Kathy Rafferty *
Dr. and Mrs. Nabih Ramadan * Mr. Robert Reda
Mr. William Redfield * Mr. John Reilly *
Mr. Lawrence
and Dr. Linda Remensnyder * Mrs. Patricia Riess *
Ms. Sandra Riggs *
Mr. Theodore Roberts * Dr. Mark Rudberg
and Ms. Ellory Peck
Mr. and Mrs. Gregory Schlax Mr. and Mrs. John Schreiber
Mrs. William Searle *
Mr. and Mrs. John Sentell Mr. and Mrs. Robert Shaw * Dr. and Mrs. Kirk Shepard Mrs. Linda Shields *
Ms. Patricia Shuma and Mr. Craig Fox *
Mr. and Mrs. Adrian Smith *
Ms. Marguerite Solberg Mr. William Springer
Col. and Mrs. Lawrence Stack * Mr. and Mrs. Harrison Steans * Mr. and Mrs. James Stebbins * Mr. and Mrs. James Stirling * Mrs. Carole Stroh *
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Thomson * Mr. and Mrs. John Travers *
Mr. and Mrs. Scott Turner Mr. and Mrs. Fred Wacker * Mr. Frank Waldeck *
Mr. and Mrs. Kevin Warnke Mr. and Mrs. Robert Washlow * Mr. and Mrs. David Waud * Ms. Nicki Weeden *
Mr. Chris Werwicki
Mr. and Mrs. Peter West * Mrs. Henry Wheeler
Ms. Lisa Wolfe
and Mr. Mark Diganci * Dr. Susanne Woloson *
- donotes LFPF Member also
DocenTs anD VolunTeers in MeMorY oF
Elizabeth Abbattista
Robert Alfe Jane Alfe Adeeba Arustu Susie Athenson
Rachel Avigard-Noel Paul Bergmann
Judy Boggess Ingrid Bryzinski Julie Carter Paula Clair
Peter Coutant Janet Cummings Michelle Curry Sue Dye
Angela Fontana Jan Gibson Tom Gleason Diane Gregg Gail Hodges Sarah Hughes Susan Ipsen
Laura Jacobson Cappy Johnston Dennis Johnston Romayne Kazmer Ted Kazmer Stewart Kerr Mark Linenberg Laura Luce
Debbie Marcusson Bill McFadden Sharon McFadden
Art Miller Pauline Mohr Roger Mohr Steven Monz Liz Moore Wendy Moreno Fred Moyer Margaret Moyer
Rosemary O’Connell Jim Opsitnik
Ellen Peter
Natalie Reinkemeyer Patricia Riess
Monica Artmann Ruggles Pam Russell
Linda Shields Linda Spanberger Jean Sullivan Sara TenBroek
Catherine Van Dorpe Caryl Vehe
Stanley D.Anderson Edward Bennett Jr. John H. Bryan Barry Carroll William J. Hughes Jeanne La Place Deborah MacKenzie
Michael and Elizabeth Rafferty Daniel M. Riess
sponsors anD in-kinD Donors in honor oF
Elizabeth and Anthony Abbattista
April’s Linens Bernie’s Book Bank Crab Tree Farm Craig Bergmann
Landscaping
Cappy Johnston JWC Media
Knauz Motor Group Kogen Friedman
Development
Lake Forest Bank & Trust Lake Forest Book Store
Lynch Construction Mariani Landscaping Market House Melichar Architects Arthur Miller Meredith Mitchell Alice Moulton-Ely
Lawrence and Linda Remensnyder
Robb Orthodontics Steve and Anna Russo Brian and Molly Sarver Jack and Renate Schuler Robert Sharoff
SilverPepper Sunset Foods
Ron and Julie Thauer The Davey Tree Expert
Company
The Organic Gardener John Vinci
Roger Mohr Jim Opsitnik
Dave and Kelly Delaney
Lake Forest Hearing
Northwest Vascular and Vein Shea Lubecke Design
UPS
DiVinci Painters Fitness Together
Lake Forest Place Lake Forest Shop
Jim and Elaine Opsitnik
Linda Shields
Webb Financial Group
Every effort was made to list the names of all our contributors. If we inadvertently omitted your name or listed it incorrectly, please contact the office at 847-234-1230 or [email protected] so we can correct our records.
Every effort was made to list the names of all our contributors. If we inadvertently omitted your name or listed it incorrectly, please contact the office at 847-234-1230 or [email protected] so we can correct our records.5
From the President
Recently I had the pleasure of seeing the 10th anniversary screening of the historical documentary Discovering Deerpath in the John and Nancy Hughes auditorium at our Gorton Community Center. The DVD is also available at the Library. The film wonderfully recreates the finding and founding of Lake Forest. It tells the stories of the many interesting and dynamic people who helped shape and then preserve our city’s character. Equally as interesting was the acknowledgement and appreciation of the many civic minded residents who have stepped forward through the decades with their time, talent and energy to make Lake Forest the community what it is today. That commitment is as important today as it was in the past, perhaps more so.
I realize that there are many demands of family, career, and everyday life that most of us face. But there often comes a time when your focus may shift and an opportunity arises to give back to the community. The varied interests of the many talented and accomplished Lake Foresters can well be matched to the diverse organizations serving the community. The learning and personal growth through the commitment to the good of the community can be very satisfying. As a thirty-five-year resident, but one who was late to this participation, I can attest to its rewards. The growth comes through the association with the many dedicated people who share similar values.
As these organizations, foundations, city boards and commissions evolve, some with term limits, new members are welcomed and needed. Lake Forest is known as a family-oriented community. So being a part of that family, it is important for individuals to step forward. The quality of life in Lake Forest is greatly enhanced by the public/private partnerships throughout the city. Forest Park, Elawa, Open Lands, Ragdale, Gorton, and the downtown train station renovation, to name a few, are the result of this collaboration.
The magical quality of life in Lake Forest is not dependent entirely upon the city, but on the continued participation of its residents. It has been an honor to serve as your President for the past two years and I look forward to continuing to serve on the Foundation’s Executive Committee.
Sincerely,
Jim Opsitnik, President
Nominations for 2019 Historic Preservation Awards
Due by March 25th
Every year, coinciding with National Historic Preservation Month, the Lake Forest Preservation Foundation honors families, businesses, and organizations that have demonstrated a commitment to excellence in preserving Lake Forest’s architectural heritage. The annual Historic Preservation Awards are based on criteria established by the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and fall into five categories, a description of each can be found on the Foundation’s website.
Preservation • Rehabilitation • Restoration Reconstruction • New Construction or Infill
Any building, structure or landscape fifty years or older is eligible to be nominated. For the category of New Construction or Infill, new and recent construction is eligible. Nominations may be made by any interested person – the owner, the designer, a neighbor or friend, an admiring passerby. Handsome bronze plaques will be presented to award recipients at the Preservation Foundation’s Annual Meeting.
Nominations for the 2019 awards are being accepted now through March 25th and can be submitted by downloading a nomination form available on the Foundation’s website, www.LFPF.org/preservation-awards, or by contacting the LFPF office, 847-234-1230 or [email protected].
Results of the First Lake Forest Preservation Foundation Survey
On January 10, 2019, the LFPF surveyed its constituents, including members, non-members, friends and donors. We received a very good response rate for a first time survey.
Gardens of the
Arts and Crafts Movement
Iconic gardens from the Arts and Crafts era defy
91%
95%
rated our programs
as very good to excellent
were satisfied with the
LF Preservation Foundation
definition. Designed to accentuate the beauty and personality of both house and region, these gardens made a lasting impact on gardens worldwide, from public parks to small cottages. Gardens of the Arts and Crafts Movement, the newest book by renowned landscape historian Judith B. Tankard, surveys the rich history of the era and unlocks the secrets to creating a garden faithful to the movement. Arts and Crafts aficionados and garden designers alike will find inspiration in hundreds of contemporary photographs and historic illustrations detailing works that stretch from Gertrude Jekyll’s Munstead Wood to storied California estates to Lake Forest’s own Ragdale.
Judith B. Tankard is a landscape historian, award-winning author, and preservation consultant.
Please join us at Gorton Community Center on May 9 at 1:00 P.M. Judith Tankard will present a program featuring her updated edition of Ellen Shipman and the American Garden, winner of the John Brinckerhoff Jackson Book Prize for 2019. Signed books will be available for sale.
Tickets are $15 at LFPF.org
The most popular programs were:
the annual house tour, closely followed by the garden strolls.
Suggestions for Improvement:
- Thheamveomstoprerepvraolgernatmcsowmimtheanrtcshwiteecrets: and owners of historic homes
we need to attract young families with children and have more educational programs
more programs about historic landscapes and their preservation
We received 16 pages of valuable comments about our programs and suggestions for how to connect with the community. We will seriously consider all ideas and we want to thank you very much for taking the time to complete the survey. Your input is very valuable to us. Special thanks to the committee members, Susan Athenson, Elizabeth Abbattista, Ingrid Bryzinski, Marcy Kerr, Elizabeth Moore, Linda Shields, and the Chair, Linda Liang.
6
e
If not now, When?
If not you, Who?
If you aren’t already a member of the LFPF, please consider joining today! With your support the Preservation Foundation can continue being your community advocate. What would Lake Forest look like without its beautiful and historic landmarks, streetscapes, parks and gardens, and historic districts? With your membership dues LFPF will continue its efforts to preserve the unique visual character of Lake Forest by:
Contributing to City meetings of the Building Review Board and Historic Preservation Commission, adding valuable insight and awareness of preservation issues.
Funding restoration projects in Lake Forest, such as most recently the historic downtown train station and the original 1857 Surveyor’s Plot Map of Lake Forest.
Presenting educational programs about preservation issues, architects, historic estates, and neighborhoods.
Offering Strolls and Tours of important Lake Forest gardens and architectural treasures.
Recognizing preservation projects throughout the city through our annual awards.
And so much more!
The time is Now to join or renew your membership to the LFPF.
With it you will be supporting our programs, communications, educational
outreach, and dedicated staff. Take part in preserving Lake Forest’s legacy.
We couldn’t do it without YOU!
e
Join the Lake Forest Preservation
Foundation today!
e
If not now, When?
If not you, Who?
If you aren’t already a member of the LFPF, please consider joining today! With your support the Preservation Foundation can continue being your community advocate. What would Lake Forest look like without its beautiful and historic landmarks, streetscapes, parks and gardens, and historic districts? With your membership dues LFPF will continue its efforts to preserve the unique visual character of Lake Forest by:
Contributing to City meetings of the Building Review Board and Historic Preservation Commission, adding valuable insight and awareness of preservation issues.
Funding restoration projects in Lake Forest, such as most recently the historic downtown train station and the original 1857 Surveyor’s Plot Map of Lake Forest.
Presenting educational programs about preservation issues, architects, historic estates, and neighborhoods.
Offering Strolls and Tours of important Lake Forest gardens and architectural treasures.
Recognizing preservation projects throughout the city through our annual awards.
And so much more!
The time is Now to join or renew your membership to the LFPF.
With it you will be supporting our programs, communications, educational
outreach, and dedicated staff. Take part in preserving Lake Forest’s legacy.
We couldn’t do it without YOU!
e
Join the Lake Forest Preservation
Foundation today!
For Jeanette and Dan Hodgkinson, buying and restoring the old white clapboard mansion on Ridge Road may have always been predestined.
Once the childhood home of Ginevra King—the lost love of F. Scott Fitzgerald and the inspiration for the character Daisy Buchanan in the book, The Great Gastsby—the house had fallen into serious disrepair over the past 10 years and its property recently subdivided.
Dan grew up down the street and was always aware of the home. He recalls his first visit to the estate as a young child. “When I was about 5 years old, I was riding my bike with my mom up Ridge Road. As we passed the property, Mr. Reilly (the previous longtime owner) was in the yard and he invited us inside for lemonade. He showed us around his beautiful house. It was really a nice gesture and goes to show you what Lake Forest was all about,” Dan explained. “When we left, Mr. Reilly told us we could come back anytime.”
“We’ve come back!” exclaims Jeanette.
The couple has been fixing and flipping houses as a hobby for several years. In fact, it’s grown into a full-time business for Jeanette who now runs Bell Design, a remodeling company that handles anything from whole house renovations to smaller kitchen, bath, and basement remodels.
“When we first drove up to this house, we realized this wasn’t another flip. This was a home we had to save,” said Jeanette.
It’s also a home they intend to make their own. Working with Susan Benjamin of Benjamin Historic Certifications, the Hodgkinsons recently submitted an application to the City of Lake Forest for Local Landmark designation, a process that will allow them to apply for the Illinois Historic Property Tax Assessment Freeze. The program freezes the assessed value of historic owner-occupied, principal residences for 8 years, followed by a four-year period during which the property’s assessed value steps up to the new level. The program is a major financial incentive for homeowners who are sensitively investing in the rehabilitation of their historic homes.
According to a report prepared by Benjamin, the main house, as originally designed in 1905 by Howard Van Doren Shaw, was considerably altered in 1938 by designer George Senseney. The remodeling has become significant in its own right because of the sensitive design. Some of Shaw’s imprint remains—but the house now mostly reflects Senseney’s influence. The interior was largely reorganized and redecorated. On the exterior, the window openings and roofs were modified to both serve the redesigned spaces and update the house’s popular Colonial Revival style.
One of the most striking features of Senseney’s design is the extensive use of Carrara glass on the walls in the master and guest suite bathrooms. Also known as pigmented structural glass, Carrara glass was available in 30 colors and manufactured in flat panels or curves, and in a wide range of sizes and thicknesses. Its use in the house is indicative of the chic, ultra-modern character of 1938 remodeling, as well as its high-end sophistication.
Walking through the home, the Hodgkinsons’ excitement for their endeavor is as apparent as their commitment to a faithful rehabilitation. “The master bathroom is the most significant room in the house and will be preserved,” said Dan. Working with the experienced local architectural firm, Landmark Development, 95% of the house will be preserved and restored, with major modifications only being made to accommodate a new master bath in the area of a sleeping porch connected to the master bedroom, as well as reconfiguration of the kitchen area.
They also intend to replace many of the decorative features that were previously stripped from the home, including crystal chandeliers and sconces in the foyer and dining room. “We have pictures of the original crystal fixtures which are being custom made to match,” said
Jeanette. “We are trying to blend the history of the original King residence with bringing in some of the Gatsby glam.”
7
LAKE FOREST PRESERVATION FOUNDATION
2018-2019
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
Jim Opsitnik
President
Peter Coutant
VP Communications
Laura V. Luce
VP Development
Elizabeth Abbattista Natalie Reinkemeyer VP Programs
Susan Rafferty Athenson
Secretary
Debbie Marcusson
Treasurer
DIRECTORS
Robert Alfe Ingrid Bryzinski Michelle Curry Angela Fontana Tom Gleason Linda Liang
William McFadden Roger Mohr Elizabeth Moore Fred Moyer
Kurt Pairitz
Monica Artmann Ruggles Sara TenBroek
HONORARY DIRECTORS
Herbert Geist Gail Hodges Arthur Miller Pauline Mohr Shirley Paddock Linda Shields Lorraine Tweed
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Marcy Kerr
Preservation
SPRING 2019
VOLUME 12, NUMBER 1
Contributors:
Gail Hodges, Marcy Kerr, Arthur Miller, Pauline Mohr, Jim Opsitnik
Editor: Peter Coutant
PhotograPhy:
Cappy Johnston
Lake Forest Preservation Foundation 400 East Illinois Road
Lake Forest, Illinois 60045 www.lfpf.org
NON-PROFIT ORG
U.S. POSTAGE
PAID PERMIT NO. 184 LAKE FOREST, IL
60045
NON-PROFIT ORG
U.S. POSTAGE
PAID PERMIT NO. 184 LAKE FOREST, IL
60045
ECRWSS
Residential Customer Lake Forest, IL 60045
Lake Forest Preservation Foundation
Programs for 2019
Visit LFPF.org for details and to register
Sunday, March 17, 2019 Historic 2nd Presbyterian Church:
3:00 PM Restoring Chicago’s Arts & Crafts Jewel
Gorton Community Center
Sunday, April 28, 2019 Annual Meeting and 2019
2:00 PM Historic Preservation Awards Gorton Community Center, Member only reception following at historic residence
Thursday, May 9, 2019 Ellen Shipman and the
1:00 PM American Garden
Judith Tankard lecture & book signing Gorton Community Center
Tickets: $15
Saturday, May 11, 2019 Howard Van Doren Shaw
8:30 AM – 1:00 PM Symposium
2nd Presbyterian Church, Chicago
www.glessnerhouse.org for tickets
Friday, June 28, 2019 Early Summer Garden Stroll
5:30 PM – 7:30 PM Members $20 Non-members $30
Saturday, July 27, 2019 Annual Summer Tour of
10:00 AM or 1:00 PM Crab Tree Farm & Art Collections
Members $20 Non-members $30
Friday, August 23, 2019 Late Summer Garden Stroll
5:30 PM – 7:30 PM Members $20 Non-members $30
Sunday, October 6, 2019 Architectural House &
1:00 PM – 4:00 PM Garden Tour, Annual Benefit
Advance ticket $100
Sunday, December 8, 2019 Annual Member
2:00 PM – 4:00 PM Holiday Celebration
Members only
